CONMEBOL U-17 Championship 2023

Ecuador, 30 March - 23 April 2023

Referee: Andres Merlos (ARG, photo)
Assistant Referee 1: Pablo Gonzalez (ARG)
Assistant Referee 2: Sebastian Raineiri (ARG)

Referee: Dilio Rodriguez (BOL)
Assistant Referee 1: Roger Orellana (BOL)
Assistant Referee 2: Ruben Flores (BOL)

Referee: Savio Pereira (BRA)
Assistant Referee 1: Guilherme Dias (BRA)
Assistant Referee 2: Nailton Sousa (BRA)

Referee: Felipe Gonzalez (CHI)
Assistant Referee 1: Juan Serrano (CHI)
Assistant Referee 2: Carlos Poblete (CHI)

Referee: Carlos Betancur (COL)
Assistant Referee 1: Miguel Roldan (COL)
Assistant Referee 2: Richard Ortiz (COL)

Referee: Augusto Aragon (ECU)
Assistant Referee 1: Juan Aguiar (ECU)
Assistant Referee 2: Andres Tola (ECU)

Referee: Michael Espinoza (PER)
Assistant Referee 1: Roberto Perez (PER)
Assistant Referee 2: Coty Carrera (PER)

Referee: Jose Burgos (URU)
Assistant Referee 1: Pablo Llarena (URU)
Assistant Referee 2: Santiago Fernandez (URU)

Referee: Angel Arteaga (VEN)
Assistant Referee 1: Carlos Lopez (VEN)
Assistant Referee 2: Antoni Garcia (VEN)

UEFA Referee Exchange
Referee: Simone Sozza (ITA)
Assistant Referee 1: Giovanni Baccini (ITA)
Assistant Referee 2: Davide Imperiale (ITA)

Support Referee
1. Roberto Perez (PER)

Support Assistant Referees
1. David Fuentes (COL)
2. Agustin Berisso (URU)

Referee Assessors
1. Patricio Loustau (ARG)
2. Luis Vera (ECU)
3. Fredy Arellanos (PER)
4. Miguel Nievas (URU)

Premier League VAR chief set to retire

Premier League video assistant referee chief Neil Swarbrick is to leave his role at the end of the season. Swarbrick moved on to lead video assistant referee duties after his on-field career came to an end in 2018. The 57-year-old has spearheaded VAR's implementation in the top flight. But he has now opted to retire amid a period of change at PGMOL triggered by the arrival of Howard Webb as chief refereeing officer. Former World Cup final referee Webb returned to English football to take up the newly created role at the end of 2022 after five years in the United States. The VAR system has endured frequent controversies since being introduced into the Premier League from the start of the 2019-20 campaign. Earlier this month Lee Mason left PGMOL following his VAR error during Arsenal's 1-1 draw with Brentford. Mason failed to draw the lines to check for offside on Ivan Toney's equaliser for the Bees and left his post just days later. Another official, John Brooks, was dropped as VAR operator for the Merseyside derby and Manchester City's top-of-the-table visit to Arsenal after wrongly disallowing a Brighton goal at Crystal Palace. This move in itself is regarded as being distinct from the furore in recent weeks that led to Mason's immediate departure from PGMOL on 17 February. However, it is part of the immense change at the organisation and the direction of travel. Webb is determined to make officials more transparent and accountable and if that means making tough decisions, that is what he will do. VAR has been a particular issue, although some of the bolder moves, including announcing decisions to fans in stadiums, are only within the remit of international rule-making body IFAB, whose annual meeting is in central London on Saturday. (Source: BBC)
In the recent Premier League match between Chelsea and Tottenham, referee Stuart Attwell caused VAR confusion by overturning Ziyech red card. Just before half-time, players from both sides squared up to each other. After a long period of deliberation, referee Stuart Attwell sent off Hakim Ziyech on the advice of his assistant, Darren Cann, alongside input from the VAR, Paul Tierney. However, after the red card was shown the VAR immediately instigated a review for a clear and obvious error. VAR decision: Red card cancelled. With the way VAR operates, everyone is left guessing - and indeed assuming this was an error in process by the officials. Yet despite all this, VAR protocol was followed to the letter. This wasn't a situation wrong on the pitch or in the VAR room. In short, even though the VAR doesn't think Ziyech's actions are a red-card offence, he cannot tell Attwell they aren't a red-card offence before Attwell has decided whether or not they are a red-card offence. Fans, pundits and indeed the match commentators (who can hear the VAR but, crucially, not the referee) were left to fill in the blanks. Until FIFA and the IFAB finally embrace the need to share the conversations between referee and VAR as they happen - both on TV and inside the stadium - the gap in understanding and acceptance will only widen.
Attwell books Havertz for an initial challenge on Richarlison before the flare up, when he took a swipe at the Tottenham striker in an attempt to trip him. Ziyech then tried to tackle Richarlison and may have won the ball. Despite the ensuing melee, Ziyech isn't considered to have committed any offence at this point. The VAR cannot tell Attwell that Ziyech should have been booked. The only way the VAR could intervene on this aspect is if Attwell had incorrectly cautioned Havertz for the challenge made by Ziyech, then the yellow could have been switched to Ziyech on mistaken identity. This could technically have resulted in Ziyech still being sent off - the red card being downgraded to yellow for the push, and the yellow shown to Havertz transferred to him. Why did the VAR help issue a red card, only to then advise it was wrong? Attwell had turned to his left just as Ziyech raised his hand toward Royal and didn't see it. It's Cann who believed he saw the hand straight into the face from a Chelsea player. A cornerstone of the VAR process is a referee must always take a decision first. So, the VAR cannot make any suggestion about a possible sanction before the referee has made his own decision, but the VAR can help with identification. Ergo, a VAR can tell the referee who the offender was, but he couldn't tell the referee if he should or shouldn't show a red card. Attwell will say to Tierney he's going to show a red card, but ask for confirmation who that player is. Once Attwell has shown the red card to Ziyech, that then brings the VAR into play for a review of the decision. This situation was unlike many others. Though it took 4½ minutes, only the final 1½ minutes actually involved the VAR process - the other three were used up by the melee, discussions among the match officials and the disciplinary action. The only difference to a normal situation is that Cann couldn't identify Ziyech; the aid of the VAR was needed for that. If you shift the process to a VAR giving his opinion on a decision before a referee has made his own mind up, then the VAR becomes the de-facto referee. The on-field decision has to remain the most important element. As Ziyech clearly didn't push Royal directly in the face, his hand slipping off the Spurs player's shoulder, a red card can be viewed as a clear and obvious error. Imagine if we were allowed to hear Attwell say to the VAR he has a red-card offence and could the VAR please confirm the player's identity? And then we hear the VAR immediately initiate the review for the error? We'd all know exactly what had happened and articles like this might not be so necessary. There will always be complicated reviews, the kind that aren't going to be explained by a referee reading out their final decision pitch side, which FIFA and the IFAB think will solve the problems over communication. (Source: ESPN)

UEFA Youth League 2022/2023 – Round of 16

28 February 2023
AC Milan – Rukh Lviv
Referee: Christian Ciochirca (AUT, photo)
Assistant Referee 1: Maximilian Weiss (AUT)
Assistant Referee 2: Michael Obritzberger (AUT)
Fourth Official: Matteo Marcenaro (ITA)
Referee Observer: Roberto Rosetti (ITA)

Hajduk Split – Manchester City
Referee: Snir Levi (ISR)
Assistant Referee 1: Idan Zoler (ISR)
Assistant Referee 2: Tuval Koltunoff (ISR)
Fourth Official: Ante Terzić (CRO)
Referee Observer: Igor Pristovnik (CRO)

Borussia Dortmund – Paris St. Germain
Referee: Goga Kikacheishvili (GEO)
Assistant Referee 1: Davit Gabisonia (GEO)
Assistant Referee 2: Davit Akhvlediani (GEO)
Fourth Official: Robin Braun (GER)
Referee Observer: Sven Bindels (LUX)

1 March 2023
Sporting CP – AFC Ajax
Referee: Matthew De Gabriele (MLT)
Assistant Referee 1: Jurgen Spiteri (MLT)
Assistant Referee 2: Mitchell Scerri (MLT)
Fourth Official: Andre Narciso (POR)
Referee Observer: Manuel Diaz Vega (ESP)

Real Madrid – FC Salzburg
Referee: Marian Barbu (ROU)
Assistant Referee 1: George Neacșu (ROU)
Assistant Referee 2: Adrian Vornicu (ROU)
Fourth Official: Pedro Munoz Piedra (ESP)
Referee Observer: Ian Stokes (IRL)

FC Barcelona – AZ Alkmaar
Referee: Ondřej Berka (CZE)
Assistant Referee 1: Matěj Vlček (CZE)
Assistant Referee 2: Lukaš Machač (CZE)
Fourth Official: David Lopez Jimenez (ESP)
Referee Observer: Salustia Cipres (AND)

Liverpool FC – FC Porto
Referee: Helgi Jonasson (ISL)
Assistant Referee 1: Egill Gudlaugsson (ISL)
Assistant Referee 2: Eysteinn Hrafnkelsson (ISL)
Fourth Official: Benjamin Speedie (ENG)
Referee Observer: Kevin Parry (WAL)

Atletico de Madrid – KRC Genk
Referee: Chrysovalandis Theouli (CYP)
Assistant Referee 1: Pavlos Georgiou (CYP)
Assistant Referee 2: Kyriakos Sokratous (CYP)
Fourth Official: Fernando Bueno Prieto (ESP)
Referee Observer: Lucilio Batista (POR)

Negreira sued by ex-FIFA referee and current VAR Estrada Fernandez

Enriquez Negreira, formerly vice-president of the Spanish FA's Technical Committee of Referees (CTA), received £1.2million from the Catalan giants between 2016 and 2018, allegedly for providing advice how to get better treatment from referees. And current official Xavier Estrada Fernandez has sued the 77-year-old for sporting corruption or receiving fraudulent payments in the latest twist to the high-profile affair which embroils Barcelona and its president Joan Laporta.
The lawsuit was presented in the courts in Barcelona on Friday and alleges that Enriquez Negreira provided advice and services 'with the aim of securing refereeing decisions favourable to the interests of FC Barcelona' while he was CTA vice-president, in different seasons from 2003 to 2018. The document shows he was paid around £1.2m by Barcelona via his company DASNIL 95 SL between 2016 and 2018, meaning he was on the payroll of one of the clubs while carrying out a supposedly neutral role for the governing body. Estrada's case is also brought against Enriquez Negreira's son Javier Enríquez Romero, who managed the company and who provided 'coaching' services to active referees when taking them from their hotel to the stadium. Estrada previously worked as a referee in LaLiga, Spanish football's top flight, but has worked as a Video Assistant Referee (VAR) since the 2021-2022 season.
Enriquez Negreira has denied ever favouring Barcelona with refereeing decisions, while the club have admitted hiring an 'external consultant' who provided reports on 'professional refereeing'. Spanish outlet El Pais report that his company sent Barcelona a written report and DVD with video analysis discussing the profile of their upcoming referee before every LaLiga and Copa del Rey game. LaLiga said on Friday it cannot investigate cases from more than three years ago, seemingly ruling out punishments like Barcelona being docked points or titles being removed. But prosecutors' investigations are ongoing and criminal charges may be brought. On Thursday, newspaper El Mundo presented documents which said Barca had paid DASNIL 95 SL more than £5.8m from 2001. El Mundo also revealed a burofax Enriquez Negreira sent to the club in 2018 after Barcelona halted payments, in which he said he would bring about a 'scandal' by 'revealing with no hesitation all the irregularities from the club I've lived through first-hand', unless payments began again. He added: 'I have the firm intention to sue the club, which would bring negative consequences for FC Barcelona.' Enriquez Negreira started working as a top-flight referee in 1979 and rose up the ranks to become CTA vice-president by 1994. He told Spanish tax authorities last week Barcelona paid him 'to make sure no refereeing decisions were made against them, which is to say, for everything to be neutral'. Barcelona, for their part, claim they have launched their own probe into the matter.

Source: Daily Mail

AFC Champions League 2022 – Semi-final (West Region)

26 February 2023

Al Hilal – Al Duhail
Referee: Ko Hyung-Jin (KOR, photo)
Assistant Referee 1: Yoon Jae-Yeol (KOR)
Assistant Referee 2: Park Sang-Jun (KOR)
Fourth Official: Fu Ming (CHN)
VAR: Kim Jong-Hyeok (KOR)

CONCACAF U-17 Championship Final 2023: Martinez (SLV)

26 February 2023

Mexico – USA
Referee: Filiberto Martinez (SLV, photo)
Assistant Referee 1: Carlos Vargas (SLV)
Assistant Referee 2: Cristian Alvarado (GUA)
Fourth Official: Jose Fuentes (GUA)

Amboya: “If they don't pay us, it's hard to feel supported”

The Ecuadorian referees claim that both the Ecuadorian Football Federation (FEF) and the LigaPro maintain debts with the entire refereeing union. FIFA AR Monica Amboya says that the referees are going through an "uncomfortable" situation from the economic point of view, and she hopes that the FEF and LigaPro will catch up on payments "as soon as possible." In the case of the Federation, the referee details that there have been debts for some years. In addition, they have not been paid for their work in the 2022 Ecuador Cup. In that tournament, Amboya was working as VAR. The Professional League owe payments, among others, for matches that were played with VAR, including the finals between Aucas and Barcelona SC. “If they don't pay us, it's hard to feel supported. When you work, the least you expect is to be paid. We feel uncomfortable knowing that there is no commitment to keep everything up to date”, says Amboya.
According to Jaime Jativa, general secretary of the Association of Professional Referees, several of his colleagues have not received their salaries since 2018. Some quit refereeing. Others look for methods to generate resources. Although the ADAFP sent a letter on 29 December 2022 to the FEF, requesting a meeting to resolve the payments, that meeting has not been held so far. They were waiting for the Ordinary Congress to take place. During the Congress, which took place on January 31 in Guayaquil, Egas admitted a debt with the Referee Associations, which exceeds USD 1.8 million. The truth is that there is a general malaise on the part of all referees towards both institutions, due to the constant delays in payments. "It is a complicated situation. We need the money. There are families that depend on us. In addition, we have a multidisciplinary team of nutritionists, physical trainers and instructors who also work for free”, says Amboya. She was appointed by FIFA to the Women’s World Cup in New Zealand and Australia, which will be played from July 20 to August 20 of this year. Amboya will be one of the tournament's 55 assistant referees and the only Ecuadorian. “It is a joy because it has been a four-year job, where I have prepared myself in the best way, leaving everything aside, including the family“. Amboya has sacrificed her time with her daughters and her loved ones to train and stay in peak condition. She did not hide her happiness at having been ratified for the competition and, at the same time, she admitted that she feels a "great responsibility" to represent the country in the best way.

Source: Primicias

CONMEBOL Libertadores 2023 – Second Round (Second Leg)

28 February - 2 March 2023

Cerro Porteno – Curico Unido
Referee: Wilmar Roldan (COL, photo)
Assistant Referee 1: Alexander Guzman (COL)
Assistant Referee 2: Dionisio Ruiz (COL)
Fourth Official: Andres Rojas (COL)
VAR: John Ospina (COL)
AVAR: David Rodriguez (COL)
Referee Assessor: Gustavo Rossi (ARG)
VAR Supervisor: Roberto Silvera (URU)

Sporting Cristal – Nacional
Referee: Cristian Garay (CHI)
Assistant Referee 1: Claudio Urrutia (CHI)
Assistant Referee 2: Miguel Rocha (CHI)
Fourth Official: Felipe Gonzalez (CHI)
VAR: Angelo Hermosilla (CHI)
AVAR: Alejandro Molina (CHI)
Referee Assessor: Cesar Escano (PER)
VAR Supervisor: Wilson Avila (ECU)

Huracan – Boston River
Referee: Wilton Sampaio (BRA)
Assistant Referee 1: Rodrigo Correa (BRA)
Assistant Referee 2: Bruno Pires (BRA)
Fourth Official: Ramon Abatti (BRA)
VAR: Rodolpho Toski (BRA)
AVAR: Daniel Nobre (BRA)
Referee Assessor: Patricio Loustau (ARG)
VAR Supervisor: Patricio Polic (CHI)

Independiente Medellin – El Nacional
Referee: Raphael Claus (BRA)
Assistant Referee 1: Danilo Manis (BRA)
Assistant Referee 2: Bruno Boschilia (BRA)
Fourth Official: Paulo Zanovelli (BRA)
VAR: Wagner Reway (BRA)
AVAR: Pablo Goncalves (BRA)
Referee Assessor: Abraham Gonzalez (COL)
VAR Supervisor: Barbra Bastias (CHI)

Atletico Mineiro – Carabobo
Referee: Diego Haro (PER)
Assistant Referee 1: Michael Orue (PER)
Assistant Referee 2: Stephen Atoche (PER)
Fourth Official: Augusto Menendez (PER)
VAR: SIlvio Trucco (ARG)
AVAR: Jonny Bossio (PER)
Referee Assessor: Ednilson Corona (BRA)
VAR Supervisor: Carlos Pastorino (URU)

Always Ready – Magallanes
Referee: Alexis Herrera (VEN)
Assistant Referee 1: Alberto Ponte (VEN)
Assistant Referee 2: Antoni Garcia (VEN)
Fourth Official: Jose Argote (VEN)
VAR: Rafael Traci (BRA)
AVAR: Rodrigo Guarizo (BRA)
Referee Assessor: Jorge Antequera (BOL)
VAR Supervisor: Wilson Lamouroux (COL)

Millonarios – Universidad Catolica
Referee: Facundo Tello (ARG)
Assistant Referee 1: Gabriel Chade (ARG)
Assistant Referee 2: Ezequiel Brailovsky (ARG)
Fourth Official: Nicolas Lamolina (ARG)
VAR: Mauro Vigliano (ARG)
AVAR: Jorge Balino (ARG)
Referee Assessor: Luzmila Gonzalez (COL)
VAR Supervisor: Sergio Cristiano (BRA)

Fortaleza – Deportivo Maldonado
Referee: Jesus Valenzuela (VEN)
Assistant Referee 1: Jorge Urrego (VEN)
Assistant Referee 2: Tulio Moreno (VEN)
Fourth Official: Guillermo Guerrero (ECU)
VAR: Carlos Orbe (ECU)
AVAR: Christian Lescano (ECU)
Referee Assessor: Ricardo Marques (BRA)
VAR Supervisor: Angel Sanchez (ARG)

Turkish referees and observers among the earthquake victims

The Turkish Football Federation (TFF) has issued a statement expressing its sadness for the victims of the earthquake, announcing that there are members of the refereeing community among them: “It is with deep sadness that we learned that some of our referees and observers, who served in various competitions, lost their lives in the earthquake disaster that shocked our country. 14 members of our referee community lost their lives and the homes of hundreds of them were destroyed. May God have mercy on our deceased referees and observers. We express our condolences to their bereaved families, loved ones and our entire football community. On this occasion, once again, we wish God's mercy for all our citizens lost in the earthquake, and the speedy recovery of our injured. Condolences to our beloved nation."

Source: TFF

CONMEBOL Recopa 2023 (Second Leg)

28 February 2023

Flamengo – Independiente Del Valle
Referee: Andres Matonte (URU, photo)
Assistant Referee 1: Nicolas Taran (URU)
Assistant Referee 2: Martin Soppi (URU)
Fourth Official: Jose Burgos (URU)
Reserve AR: Andres Nievas (URU)
VAR: Andres Cunha (URU)
AVAR 1: Gustavo Tejera (URU)
AVAR 2: Richard Trindad (URU)
AVAR 3: Leodan Gonzalez (URU)
Referee Assessor: Angel Sanchez (ARG)
VAR Supervisor: Juan Cardellino (URU)